top of page
Search

My IRA can own Private Loans?

Updated: 2 hours ago

PRIVATE LOANS

Investing in private notes offers another opportunity for individuals seeking alternative income streams beyond the bucking bronco of the traditional stock market. Private notes are debt instruments created through private agreements, often involving real estate or business loans. They can provide steady, pre-determined cash flow and attractive returns, but they can also carry the natural risk of lending, such as default.


Your Self-Directed IRA (SDIRA) is a better entity choice to own a loan because the interest is either tax-free or tax-deferred when withdrawn in retirement. If you lent money, you would owe income tax & Obamacare tax (NII) on your 1040 on the interest income!


THE BENEFITS OF YOUR IRA AS A LENDER


If you owned a loan personally, you would be required to pay tax on the interest income on your annual 1040. But this is NOT true in your Self-Directed IRA


  • The interest rate and, therefore, return on investment is a known quantity.

  • The Interest Income is NOT taxable in the year as it is earned and paid to your IRA.

  • ZERO Income Tax, Net Investment Income (NII) Tax or any State Income Tax.

  • TAX-FREE to a ROTH IRA

  • TAX-DEFERRED to a Traditional IRA

  • Earnings can compound in a tax-free environment.


Close-up view of a signed loan agreement document on a wooden table
Private note agreement document ready for investment


What Are Private Notes?


Private notes are promissory notes issued in private transactions rather than through public markets. Therefore, they must They represent a borrower's promise to repay a loan under agreed terms, including interest rate, payment schedule, and maturity date. Unlike publicly traded bonds, private notes are not registered with regulatory bodies and are typically held by individual investors or small groups.


Common types of private notes include:


  • Real estate notes: Loans secured by property, such as mortgages or trust deeds.

  • Business notes: Loans made to companies for working capital or expansion.

  • Personal notes: Loans to individuals, either with or without collateral.


Private notes can be short-term or long-term and usually offer higher interest rates than traditional bank deposits or government bonds. This higher yield compensates for the increased risk and lower liquidity.


How Private Notes Work


When you invest in a private note, you essentially become the lender. The borrower agrees to pay you back the principal amount plus interest over time. Payments may be monthly, quarterly, or as a lump sum at maturity.


Here’s a simplified example:


  • You buy a private note for $50,000.

  • The note pays 10% annual interest.

  • The borrower makes monthly payments of principal and interest.

  • After 5 years, the loan is fully repaid.


Your income comes from the interest payments, and your principal is returned at the end of the loan term. Some notes allow early repayment or refinancing, which can affect your returns.


Benefits of Investing in Private Notes


Investing in private notes has several advantages:


  • Steady income: Regular interest payments provide predictable cash flow.

  • Tax Free and Tax Deferred Growth on Returns

  • Higher returns: Interest rates on private notes often exceed those of traditional fixed-income investments. 10-18% depending on states and loan amounts.

  • Collateral security: Private notes can be secured by assets like real estate or cars, reducing risk.

  • Portfolio diversification: variety added to your existing investment mix lowers overall risk.

  • Direct control: You negotiate terms and choose borrowers that fit your risk tolerance.


For example, a retiree seeking monthly income might invest in a real estate note secured by a rental property. The borrower’s monthly payments generate steady cash flow, while the property acts as collateral.


Risks to Consider


Private notes are not without risks. Understanding these is crucial before investing:


  • Default risk: Borrowers may fail to make payments, leading to loss of income or principal. Renegotiating terms of the loan can mitigate defaults. For example, increasing interest rate when a payment is missed.

  • Illiquidity: Private notes are not easily sold, so your money may be tied up for the loan's term. This risk is another reason why the IRA is a better lender than your personal after-tax direct investments.

  • Lack of regulation: Private notes are less regulated than public securities. By using IRA money as the lender, it lends more formality to a personal loan.

  • Legal complexities: Enforcing loan agreements may require legal action, which can be costly and time-consuming.


For instance, if a borrower defaults on a real estate note, you may need to initiate foreclosure proceedings to recover your investment, which could take months or years.


Tips for Successful Investing


To improve your chances of success, follow these tips:


  • Start small: Begin with a modest investment to learn the process.

  • Diversify: Spread investments across multiple notes and borrowers.

  • Verify documentation: Always review legal paperwork with a qualified attorney.

  • Check borrower history: Look for consistent payment records.

  • Understand the collateral: If secured, confirm the asset’s value and condition.

  • Plan for illiquidity: Be prepared to hold the note until maturity.

  • Stay informed: Monitor payments and borrower status regularly.


Real-Life Example


Consider Jane, a 55-year-old investor wanted to grow her ROTH IRA with steady income without stock market volatility. The ROTH purchased a $100,000 private note secured by a rental property that was in the neighborhood where her own vacation home was. Jane knew the owners and was very familiar with rental income streams in the area including her own vacation rentals.


The note paid 10% interest annually with monthly payments. Over five years, Jane received $10,000 per year in interest, plus her principal back at the end of the term. She earned $50,000 in interest income.


Since her ROTH IRA is a tax-free vehicle, the $50,000of interest income, accumulated tax-free and all reinvestments of this income will also grow tax-free. In retirement, all future withdrawals will be tax-free to Jane.


Jane avoided worrying about riding the ups and downs as a passive investor in the stock market. By taking control of her investment choices, she was actively involved in weighing the risks of this loan in her retirement portfolio. Additionally, she felt that she was protecting the market value of her own vacation home, because her neighbors used the loan proceeds to fix up the exterior of their property. An overall benefit to the neighborhood's home values.



Investing in private notes can be a rewarding way to increase your retirement accounts, generate income, and diversify your portfolio while collaborating with people you know and trust.





Disclaimer: This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute tax or financial advice.

 
 
 
bottom of page